The True Story of Christmas: Separating Tradition from Scripture
🎄 We all know the nativity story, right? Mary, Joseph, a stable, three wise men, and a baby sleeping peacefully while the world rejoices. It’s picture-perfect—but what if the real story was even better? Let’s look at the True Story of Christmas. 🎄
Let’s set the scene, but this time, not through the soft glow of Christmas lights or the serene calm of a nativity play. Instead, picture Bethlehem during a government-mandated census.
The town is bustling, teeming with people who have traveled from near and far to register. There are donkeys braying, children crying, vendors shouting about fresh bread, and the constant hum of hundreds of conversations. The air smells of sweat, animals, and smoky cooking fires. Streets are packed shoulder-to-shoulder as families search for places to stay, their faces weary from days of travel.
Mary and Joseph, having made the arduous journey from Nazareth, finally arrive. Exhausted, they’re met with slammed doors and apologetic shrugs. Every inn is full. The census has stretched Bethlehem’s capacity beyond its limits. Joseph’s anxiety is palpable—his wife is about to give birth, and there’s no room in sight.
This isn’t the tranquil, holy silence we imagine. The scene is chaotic—crowded, noisy, and full of commotion. And it’s here, in the middle of this messy, ordinary humanity, that God chose to make His extraordinary entrance into the world.
The True Story of Christmas Myth #1: Jesus Was Born on December 25th
December 25th is practically synonymous with Christmas but is it the True Story of Christmas. It’s the date etched into calendars, sung in carols, and lit up with festive cheer. But the reality is, the Bible doesn’t give us a birthdate for Jesus. So, how did we end up celebrating His birth on December 25th, and is this date universal across the world? Let’s unwrap the history.
Why December 25th?
The selection of December 25th as the day to celebrate Christ’s birth likely stems from a combination of practical and symbolic reasons:
- Replacing Pagan Celebrations:
In the Roman Empire, December 25th marked a popular pagan festival, Dies Natalis Solis Invicti (the Birthday of the Unconquered Sun), celebrating the winter solstice. Early Christians saw an opportunity to redirect this celebration toward the true “Light of the World”—Jesus Christ (John 8:12). - Theological Symbolism:
Some early theologians speculated that Jesus’ conception took place on March 25th (the Feast of the Annunciation), placing His birth nine months later in December. While there’s no scriptural basis for this calculation, it provided a neat and symbolic timeline. - Unified Worship:
As Christianity spread, church leaders sought a unified date to celebrate Jesus’ birth, and December 25th gradually became the standard across the Western Church.
Do All Countries Celebrate on December 25th?
Interestingly, not all Christians celebrate Christmas on December 25th. In many parts of the world, different traditions and calendars come into play:
- January 7th (Orthodox Christians):
Churches that follow the Julian calendar, such as the Russian Orthodox and Coptic Orthodox Churches, celebrate Christmas on January 7th. This date corresponds to December 25th in the Julian calendar, which is 13 days behind the Gregorian calendar used in most of the world. - January 6th (Epiphany or Three Kings’ Day):
In some countries, like Spain and parts of Latin America, January 6th is the primary celebration, marking the visit of the Magi to Jesus. While December 25th is acknowledged, Epiphany often takes center stage. - Varied Dates Across Cultures:
In Armenia, Christmas is celebrated on January 6th, combining the nativity with the feast of the Epiphany.
Does the Date Really Matter?
As we look at the True Story of Christmas the beauty of Christmas isn’t found in the exact date but in the event it commemorates—the birth of Jesus Christ, Emmanuel, God with us (Matthew 1:23). Whether celebrated in December or January, the essence of Christmas remains the same: the celebration of God’s love entering the world.
So, while December 25th has become the globally recognized date for Christmas, it’s not universal or biblical. Instead, it’s a chosen day to focus our hearts on the greatest gift humanity has ever received. As you celebrate this year, remember: the date isn’t as important as the Savior we honor!
The True Story of Christmas Myth #2: The Three Wise Men Were at the Manger
We’ve all seen it: nativity scenes with shepherds on one side, three regal wise men on the other, and everyone gathered around a peacefully sleeping baby Jesus in the manger. It’s a beautiful image—but not what Scripture tells us.
Who Were the Wise Men, and Where Did They Come From?
The Gospel of Matthew describes the wise men (or Magi) as coming “from the east” (Matthew 2:1). These men were likely scholars or astrologers, possibly from Persia, Babylon, or Arabia. Magi were known for studying the stars, and their knowledge of the celestial event that led them to Jesus suggests they were familiar with Jewish prophecies about the Messiah (perhaps from the time of the Jewish exile in Babylon).
Their gifts—gold, frankincense, and myrrh—also hint at their origins. These luxury items were typical of trade in Arabia and the surrounding regions, further supporting the idea that the Magi traveled a great distance to reach Bethlehem.
The Timing of Their Arrival
Here’s where the myth breaks down. Matthew 2:11 tells us the Magi found Jesus in a “house,” not a stable, and referred to Him as a “child,” not a baby. This suggests their visit occurred well after Jesus’ birth—potentially months or even up to two years later.
Their long journey likely began when they first saw the star, which led them to Jerusalem to inquire about the newborn King of the Jews. After consulting with Herod and the Jewish religious leaders, they followed the star to Bethlehem and worshiped Jesus, presenting their gifts.
How Their Visit Led to Herod’s Atrocity
When the Magi arrived in Jerusalem, they asked King Herod where they could find the newborn “King of the Jews.” Herod, a paranoid and power-hungry ruler, was immediately alarmed. Hearing of a potential rival to his throne, he summoned the Jewish religious leaders to confirm where the Messiah was prophesied to be born. They pointed to Bethlehem, based on Micah 5:2.
After the Magi found Jesus and were warned in a dream not to return to Herod, they went home by another route. Herod, enraged and feeling deceived, ordered the massacre of all male children in Bethlehem who were two years old and younger. His decision to target this age range was likely based on the Magi’s report of when the star first appeared, leading him to conclude that Jesus could be as old as two.
The Fulfillment of Prophecy
Herod’s horrific act, while tragic, fulfilled Old Testament prophecy. Matthew 2:17-18 quotes Jeremiah 31:15:
“A voice was heard in Ramah, weeping and great mourning, Rachel weeping for her children; and she refused to be comforted, because they were no more.”
This prophecy, written centuries before, foreshadowed the sorrow that would sweep through Bethlehem as a result of Herod’s actions.
Additionally, the Magi’s visit also fulfills prophecy about nations bringing gifts to the Messiah. Isaiah 60:3 and Psalm 72:10-11 speak of kings and nations bringing tribute to the King of Kings, symbolizing the universal nature of Jesus’ mission.
What Can We Learn from the Magi?
The Magi remind us that the story of Jesus isn’t confined to a single moment or a single group of people. These foreigners traveled great distances, seeking the Savior with hearts full of faith. Their journey, gifts, and worship demonstrate that Jesus came for all people, not just for Israel.
So, while the wise men weren’t present at the manger, their role in the Christmas story is no less significant. Their visit set in motion events that fulfilled prophecy, revealed God’s sovereignty, and emphasized the global significance of Christ’s birth. As we reflect on the Magi, let’s be inspired by their faith, their persistence, and their recognition of the King who changed everything.
The True Story of Christmas Myth #3: Jesus Was Born in a Wooden Stable
When we think of Jesus’ birth, many of us picture a cozy wooden stable, complete with hay bales, wooden beams, and neatly arranged animals. While this image has become a beloved part of Christmas traditions, it’s not the True Story of Christmas that the Bible describes—and it’s unlikely to be historically accurate.
What Does the Bible Say?
Luke 2:7 tells us:
“She gave birth to her firstborn son. She wrapped him snugly in strips of cloth and laid him in a manger because there was no lodging available for them.”
Notice what’s missing? There’s no mention of a wooden stable, barn, or even an innkeeper turning them away. The idea of a stable likely comes from the mention of a manger—a feeding trough for animals. This led to the assumption that Jesus was born in a barn or stable where animals were kept.
Why a Wooden Stable is Unlikely
- Geography and Construction in First-Century Judea
Wood was scarce and expensive in the region, so most structures were made of stone or were natural caves. Caves were often used as shelters for animals because they provided natural protection from the elements and were easy to clean. - Homes with Animal Shelters
In many first-century homes, animals were kept on the lower level of the house, while the family lived in an upper room. The manger would have been part of this lower area, not in a separate barn. This aligns with the Gospel account that Mary and Joseph couldn’t find space in the “guest room” (often translated as “inn”) and likely stayed in the family’s main living area where the animals were housed. - The Role of Hospitality
Hospitality was a cornerstone of Jewish culture. Mary and Joseph were likely not completely turned away, as extended families or strangers often offered space to travelers. However, the census had filled the guest rooms, leaving them to stay in the common area with the animals.
Archaeological Evidence
Archaeological discoveries in Bethlehem and surrounding areas support the idea that Jesus was born in a cave or a lower-level area of a home.
- Church of the Nativity:
The Church of the Nativity in Bethlehem, built in the 4th century by Emperor Constantine’s mother, Helena, is traditionally recognized as the site of Jesus’ birth. Beneath the church lies a grotto, a natural cave, which early Christians revered as the place where Jesus was born. - Cultural Practices in the Region:
Archaeologists excavating in Bethlehem and nearby towns have confirmed that people commonly used caves as shelters for themselves and their animals. These discoveries align with the biblical account of a manger, as people often carved feeding troughs directly into the rock walls of these caves. - Mangers in Ancient Judea:
Archaeological evidence shows that mangers were typically made of stone, not wood. Stone mangers were durable, practical, and commonly found in areas where animals were kept.
The Significance of the Setting
The humble setting of Jesus’ birth carries profound spiritual symbolism. The King of Kings wasn’t born in a palace but in the simplest of circumstances, emphasizing His humility and accessibility to all people. This contrast is a powerful reminder that God’s love reaches into the most ordinary and overlooked places.
What Can We Take Away?
Knowing that Jesus was likely born in a cave or lower-level home area rather than a wooden stable helps us appreciate the historical and cultural context of His birth. It also challenges us to see the beauty in simplicity and to marvel at how God chose to enter the world—not with grandeur but with grace.
So, while our wooden stable scenes may warm our hearts, the reality is even more meaningful. Jesus’ birth in a stone manger, surrounded by the ordinary sights and sounds of daily life, reminds us that God works through the ordinary to bring about the extraordinary. As we reflect on His humble beginnings, let’s remember the depth of His love and the lengths He went to be with us.
Other Myths About Christmas
The story of Jesus’ birth inspires wonder, but over the centuries, people have added many traditions that Scripture does not support. Here are a few more myths to consider as you look at the True Story of Christmas:
The Angels Sang to the Shepherds
The Myth: The heavenly host is often depicted as singing “Gloria in excelsis Deo” to announce Jesus’ birth to the shepherds.
The Reality: Luke 2:13-14 says the angels were “praising God and saying, ‘Glory to God in the highest heaven.’” The text doesn’t mention singing. While they may have sung, this detail is a tradition, not a scriptural fact.
The Star Was Visible to Everyone
The Myth: The Christmas star illuminated the entire sky, guiding everyone to Jesus.
The Reality: Matthew 2:2 notes that the Magi saw the star “in the east.” There’s no indication that it was visible or significant to anyone else. Only those with knowledge of prophecy or astronomy may have recognized it as a celestial event.
The Magi Were Kings
The Myth: The “three kings” traveled to worship Jesus, bringing gifts fit for royalty.
The Reality: The Bible refers to them as “Magi,” likely astrologers or scholars, not kings. Their gifts—gold, frankincense, and myrrh—were valuable. However, the idea of them being royalty likely comes from Old Testament prophecies, such as Isaiah 60:3, about kings bringing tribute to the Messiah.
There Were Three Wise Men
The Myth: The Magi are always depicted as three men, each bearing a specific gift.
The Reality: The Bible doesn’t specify how many Magi visited Jesus. The idea of three wise men comes from the three gifts they brought. However, there could have been more or fewer Magi.
Jesus Was Born at Midnight
The Myth: claims Jesus was born at midnight, based on traditions like midnight mass and the song It Came Upon a Midnight Clear. However, the Bible gives no specific time for His birth.
The Reality: The Bible doesn’t provide a specific time of day for Jesus’ birth. Midnight is a tradition, not a scriptural fact.
What’s the Point of the True Story of Christmas?
Understanding the historical and biblical realities of Jesus’ birth doesn’t diminish its significance; it makes it even more awe-inspiring. The King of Kings didn’t enter the world with grandeur but with humility. He wasn’t born in a palace but in a humble setting, surrounded by the messy reality of life.
Christmas isn’t about perfect nativity scenes or idealized traditions. It’s about God coming into the ordinary, messy, and imperfect to bring hope, salvation, and light.
Closing Thoughts on the True Story of Christmas
The real story of Christmas is more compelling than any tradition or myth. It’s a story of faith, love, and a God who stepped into our chaos to bring peace.
What surprised you most about the true story of Christmas? Share this post with your friends and family, and let’s reflect on the incredible gift of Jesus this season.
And don’t forget—next week, we’ll have another Christmas blog as we “Unwrap Christmas”!
🎄 Let’s rediscover the wonder of the True Story of Christmas together! 🎄
Please Follow and Like our Facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/discipleblueprint
Check out our other blogs: Disciple Blueprint Blogs
Want to stay connected to our website? Consider joining our Monthly Newsletter by completing the form below:
Pingback: The True Story of Christmas: Myths About Mary and Joseph - Disciple Blueprint